My stupid noise journey
A tale of bad choices
Interested in how to be a big dumb idiot and over-complicate things and waste time and money and endure tons of stress and some real physical pain all by thinking that you’re cleverer than you actually are? (No?)
Looking back, I was always sensitive to noise but never realized it was the cause of my little bursts of stress and distraction. That link became clear a couple of years ago when I moved into a new place and discovered that my upstairs neighbors had a lifestyle composed principally of stomping. And that there was noise from the nearby park every day from 6 AM to 2 AM. And that my sanity was retreating.
Some friends, trying to be helpful, asked “why don’t you move?” and “why don’t you get noise-canceling headphones?”
Why don’t I? Because I am scientific and rational. Since this was so important—the noise extinguishing what glimmers of joy I might otherwise have wrung from life—I decided to use my big juicy brain and work from first principles.
My research said active noise cancellation wasn’t the answer. That worked well for steady noise like aircraft engines, but I faced low-frequency, intermittent noise. What I needed was passive noise isolation—more molecules between the noise and my eardrums.
So I bought noise-blocking earmuffs like construction workers use, along with soft moldable silicone earplugs. I proudly blogged about how cheap and effective these were when used together.
Time went by. They were very quiet! But:
They made conversation impossible.
The earmuffs look really stupid.
There’s no way to play music or white noise. (Earbuds inside the earmuffs don’t work because they get knocked out of position and then can’t be adjusted.)
After 20-30 minutes, the earmuffs become uncomfortable and then escalate into ever-higher levels of pain.
Because of all this, I didn’t use them much and mostly just suffered the noise. I’d often read in hopes of finding a better solution. I found out about the ABCC1 gene that determines if you have dry or wet earwax. And I rediscovered the precedence effect where a sound that’s mostly coming from one direction can seem to come from a different direction. And I created a mathematical model of bluetooth speaker usage. These did not solve my problem.
Also around this time, I used caulk to seal up my windows, which maybe helped a bit. And I tried noise-canceling headphones on planes a couple times, which were great, but planes aren’t stomping neighbors.
Then I went away for a few months. Some of the places I stayed had moments of actual silence. Upon my return—my neighbors having meanwhile redoubled their commitment to Stomp Life—I realized I needed to move. But in the meantime, I still needed a solution.
I did yet more research. Should I meditate? Build some kind of isolation chamber? Create white noise with a frequency spectrum matched to stomping?
I kept coming back to the sad reality that nothing would work as well as the damn earmuffs. If only they weren’t so painful! But some people apparently wear them all day, so maybe I could get used to them. I spent weeks trying to persist through the discomfort with little result. When that didn’t work, I decided to harden up and endure the earmuffs until the pain became truly unbearable. Sometimes it would be so intense that I’d have a headache for an hour after. Still I couldn’t get past 45 minutes.
Maybe I needed different earmuffs? I learned about earmuffs made for shooting which have headphones inside, along with active electronics to play outside noises for “situational awareness”. I bought a pair, and then two more. All were horrendous. They were more uncomfortable, and repeated all noises, including the ones I wanted to block. The audio was awful and had a constant electronic squeal even more annoying than the original noise.
I tried kits for making custom-molded earplugs. One hardly blocked any noise. Another had a small piece immediately break off deep inside my ear, resulting in legendary good times trying to remove it with a screw.
Then I learned about earmuffs made for pilots. They were two orders of magnitude more expensive, yes, but maybe they would work better? What’s a couple thousand thousand dollars compared to my sanity?
I did yet more research on passive and active noise cancellation. While most people said active noise cancellation only works for steady sounds, a few grumpy people argued it was fine, as long as the sounds were low-frequency. The debate hinged on technical aspects of phase detection and the relative speeds of light and sound. Reading it, I couldn’t tell who was right.
Gradually it dawned on me that I didn’t understand anything. Not the physics of sound, not how ears and brains perceive it, not how active noise cancellation works, and not even how passive noise blocking works. Nothing.
And since I didn’t understand anything, perhaps I should discard theory and just try stuff? In particular, why hadn’t I tried active noise-canceling headphones?
So I bought some. The ones everyone has, that are advertised to be quiet and comfortable.
And they were… incredible. The effect on my low-frequency intermittent sounds was far better than the earmuffs. They were so good that when testing them I had to repeatedly check that the noise didn’t happen to stop the moment I put them on. They have integrated speakers and microphones, can be taken off in a second for conversation, and are comfortable enough to wear for hours.
Never satisfied, I tried some other models. But, no—the model that everyone says are the best were indeed the best.
So let’s review: I had a problem. The ultimate solution to my problem was to do the most obvious possible thing. But I convinced myself that wouldn’t work and spent two years trying everything else.
Or, OK, it’s worse than that.
I dismissed the obvious thing because I thought I was using first-principles thinking. But what were those first principles? Certainly, I don’t understand how sound works beyond some vague idea of waves of molecules smashing into each other. And I don’t understand how active noise cancellation works, beyond the broad concept of using microphones and speakers to create destructive interference.
I guess those vague ideas are correct. But they are extremely superficial, so much so that they barely predict anything. Not only was I too ignorant to work from first principles, I was too ignorant to tell if other people knew what they were talking about.
And at the same time, there was no need for first-principles thinking because testing was very fast and cheap. (At least if you return stuff that doesn’t work.) You know within seconds if noise is being blocked and within hours if you’re comfortable. It’s absurd to spend countless hours theorizing when experiments are so easy.
How? I spent years enduring noise and some weeks borderline torturing myself trying to acclimate to the earmuffs, all while I had no idea what solutions would work, and I hadn’t tried all the easy-to-try stuff. How could I be so stupid?
One answer is that I was using an overly broad heuristic. I generally think most people trust self-experimentation too much for mundane life problems. If you want to gain muscle, doing your own research on different exercise programs is rough going because the feedback loops are long and convoluted. So I generally try to “find the best practices and follow them”. That’s a good heuristic! But this particular problem had no (legible) best practices and had a very short feedback loop.
Another answer is that it’s easy to overlook your ignorance when dealing with familiar things. Sound is complicated, yes, but it’s not obviously complicated. People hear stuff all the time but rarely report being confused by it. Articles on noise blocking don’t have “WARNING: ACOUSTIC ENGINEERING IS A WHOLE FIELD” at the top. It’s easy to read a superficial explanation and not notice that there’s no content in it.
And finally, there’s “cleverness”. I’m naturally drawn to unusual solutions. A world where every problem was best solved by doing the obvious thing would be, to me, a dull world. I want to believe that there’s free utility out there, that you can make different/weirder choices and grab it. So did I let this hope distort my view of what was?
I’m not sure. But imagine an alternate history where I had bought noise-canceling headphones in the first step, but they were terrible and I suffered with them for two years before finding some weird solution that really worked. Would I feel as stupid in that branch of the timeline as I do in this one? Of course not. So if this bias exists, I’ve decided to give myself a pass on it for now.